Selective Soldering vs Wave Soldering: Which Method is Best for Your PCB Assembly Needs?

Soldering is a critical process in electronics manufacturing that allows electronic components to be permanently joined using a metal alloy called solder. The strength and conductivity of the solder connections are crucial for creating reliable electronic circuits and products. While hand soldering is still used for some applications, most electronics manufacturing relies on automated soldering processes to achieve consistent, high-quality solder joints at high volumes.

The two most common types of automated soldering are wave soldering and selective soldering. Both processes have their advantages and disadvantages depending on the type of product and production environment. Understanding the key differences between these two soldering methods is important for selecting the best approach for an application.

This article provides an overview of wave and selective soldering, their main applications and benefits, and the latest advancements in these technologies. Whether you are looking to set up a new soldering process or optimize an existing one, this guide will help identify the ideal soldering solution for your manufacturing needs.

What is Wave Soldering?

Wave soldering is a bulk soldering process used in the manufacture of printed circuit boards (PCBs). The PCBs are passed over a pan of molten solder in which a standing wave of solder is created by a pump. As the PCB makes contact with the crest of the wave, the components become soldered to the board.

Wave soldering is an efficient way to solder high volumes of PCBs with through-hole components. The entire bottom side of the PCB makes contact with the solder wave in a single pass. This enables dozens or even hundreds of solder joints to be completed simultaneously.

Wave soldering is commonly used in the production of consumer electronics, computers, telecommunications equipment and other electronic devices. It allows for the quick soldering of components like resistors, capacitors, connectors and integrated circuits to PCBs. The process is fast, consistent and repeatable.

Some key benefits of wave soldering are its speed, consistency, and ability to solder SMT and through-hole components in a single process. It also requires less operator skill compared to manual soldering. The equipment has a small footprint and low initial investment compared to other soldering methods.

What is Selective Soldering?

Selective soldering is a soldering process that allows precise application of solder to individual joints on a printed circuit board (PCB). It is called “selective” because unlike wave soldering, which soldering every joint, selective soldering only solders the specific joints that need solder.

The selective soldering process involves using a miniaturized solder wave fountain inside a nozzle that is precisely controlled. The PCB is held in place by a fixture and the nozzle locates the targeted solder joints through optical recognition. Once in position over the joint, the solder fountain is activated, applying a small and highly controlled amount of solder directly to the joint.

Selective soldering is commonly used for soldering sensitive components like surface mount devices (SMDs) that may get damaged by the high temperatures of wave soldering. It allows soldering of selective components after other soldering processes like reflow soldering have been completed. This makes selective soldering ideal for prototyping, rework, and low-to-medium volume production.

KY-AS Selective Wave Soldering Machine

Online production for front and rear sections, suitable for diverse single and double-sided board products. Stable transportation system with high control accuracy. Integrated spray, preheating, and soldering for easy operation and maintenance. Original imported FLUX point jet nozzle ensures stability. Simple and fast offline or online programming.

Key Differences

Wave soldering and selective soldering have some key differences in terms of speed, applicability, cost, and quality:

  • Speed – Wave soldering is significantly faster than selective soldering. Wave soldering can solder several hundred PCBs per hour, while selective soldering machines typically solder around 10-20 PCBs per hour.
  • Applicability – Wave soldering is only suitable for through-hole components, while selective soldering can be used for both through-hole and surface mount components. Selective soldering allows soldering of mixed technology PCBs.
  • Cost – Wave soldering systems are less expensive compared to selective soldering systems. A basic wave soldering system can cost around $50,000 while a selective soldering system may cost $100,000 or more. The running costs of wave soldering are also lower.
  • Quality – Selective soldering provides higher quality solder joints compared to wave soldering. It allows precise control over each solder joint leading to less defects. The minimized thermal exposure also results in less component damage. Wave soldering can lead to issues like solder bridging, icicling, and flux residue.

Overall, wave soldering is faster and cheaper but selective soldering provides higher flexibility and quality. The choice depends on factors like production volumes, PCB technology, and quality requirements.

When to Use Wave Soldering

Wave soldering is ideal for high-volume production runs in the tens or hundreds of thousands of units. The initial setup takes time and cost, including designing and fabricating a pallet and stencil for the PCB. However, once dialed in, wave soldering delivers extremely fast throughput at the lowest cost per board.

The continuous flow solder process can reliably solder up to 15,000 component leads per hour. With a typical board containing several hundred solder joints, production rates easily reach several thousand boards per hour. This high-speed production capability makes wave soldering well-suited for assembling consumer electronics, computers, automotive electronics, and other products manufactured in large volumes.

With a properly optimized process, wave soldering can achieve excellent solder joint quality and reliability. The automated nature of the process delivers consistency across thousands of boards. While selective soldering allows more flexibility in small batches, wave soldering provides unparalleled efficiency and control at high volumes. Manufacturers look to wave soldering for complex double-sided assemblies when making thousands of identical boards.

When to Use Selective Soldering

Selective soldering is best suited for lower to medium volume production runs where flexibility and precision are needed. Here are some of the main situations where selective soldering shines:

Low or Medium Volume Production

  • Selective soldering is ideal for lower volume boards, as low as a single prototype board. The specialized soldering heads can solder specific points without requiring an entire board to be processed through a wave solder machine. This makes it more practical and affordable for lower volume production.
  • For medium volumes in the hundreds or low thousands, selective soldering is still preferred over wave soldering. The setup costs are lower compared to wave soldering, and it avoids wasting solder materials.

Rework and Fixing Errors

  • Selective soldering is extremely useful for reworking solder joints, replacing damaged components, and fixing solder errors or defects on a completed board. Operators can quickly and precisely resolder only the problem areas.

Prototyping and Development

  • During prototyping and development, board designs often change. Selective soldering allows easy modification and rework as the board design evolves. Engineers can solder new component placements without affecting the rest of the board.

Complex and High Density Boards

  • Selective soldering can handle complex board geometries and high component densities that are problematic for wave soldering. The precision heads can reach into tight spaces and solder difficult locations.

The focused heat and control of selective soldering makes it ideal for lower volume production runs, rework, prototyping, and challenging board layouts. It offers flexibility and precision that traditional wave soldering cannot match.

Wave Soldering Pros and Cons

Wave soldering offers several advantages as well as some limitations compared to selective soldering:

Pros

  • Speed: Wave soldering is extremely fast. PCBs can be soldered at rates over 150 boards per hour. This high speed makes it ideal for mass production environments.
  • Ease: The wave soldering process is straightforward and does not require a skilled operator. Once the machine parameters are dialed in, it can reliably solder many boards with minimal supervision.
  • Low Cost: The equipment cost for wave soldering machines is relatively affordable compared to other soldering methods. When amortized over many production runs, the per board cost is very low.

Cons

  • Limited Flexibility: Wave soldering is best suited for simple, through-hole PCB designs. It does not work well for boards with dense components, fine pitch parts, or double-sided assemblies.
  • Not Suitable for SMT: The wave soldering process applies solder to the bottom side of the PCB only. It cannot solder surface mount components. For boards with a mix of through-hole and SMT parts, selective soldering would be required for the SMTs.
  • Part Sensitivity: Some component types like electrolytic capacitors or connectors with thermoplastic parts may not withstand the high temperatures of the solder wave. The process must be validated for the board’s components.
  • Solder Bridging: Due to the blanket application of solder, there is a risk of solder bridges between joints that are in close proximity. Careful process control is required.

Selective Soldering Pros and Cons

Selective soldering offers several advantages over wave soldering:

Flexibility

  • Allows soldering of very small components and fine-pitch devices that would be damaged by wave soldering.
  • Better for PCBs with mixed technology – through-hole and SMT components.
  • Can solder selective components without exposing the entire board.

Higher Quality

  • Provides greater process control, improving solder joint quality and reliability.
  • Minimizes thermal stress on components compared to wave soldering.
  • Lower potential for defects like solder bridges.

Ease of Rework

  • Easier to rework and replace individual components if needed, without desoldering the entire board.

However, selective soldering has some disadvantages compared to wave soldering:

Slower Speed

  • Lower throughput since components are soldered individually rather than all at once.
  • Production rates typically top out around 150-200 units per hour.

Higher Operational Costs

  • More expensive equipment investment than wave soldering.
  • Typically requires nitrogen for an inert atmosphere during soldering.
  • More operator training required.

So in summary, selective soldering provides higher flexibility and quality at the cost of slower speed and higher costs compared to wave soldering. It excels at soldering small, delicate components and mixed technology boards.

Scroll to Top